Duma
Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and PovertyThe Duma was established by the Russian tsar in 1905 as the country’s first national representative assembly, ending a long absence of political representation without ending absolutist rule. Its brief, constrained authority illustrates the book’s distinction between creating a formal institution and redistributing the power needed for that institution to shape policy.
Creation under absolutism
The Duma appeared in a political system organized around the tsar and a narrow supporting elite. In nineteenth-century Russia, the nobility represented about 1 percent of the population and helped sustain the ruler’s power. Until 1905, other groups in Russian society had no Parliament or political representation. The creation of the Duma therefore marked a change in the formal structure of government, but not the arrival of broad political pluralism.
Limited authority
The tsar quickly undermined the few powers he had granted the Duma. Its creation did not impose an effective constraint on his rule or ensure that other groups could influence state policy. The institution’s limited authority reflected the imbalance between a representative body on paper and an absolutist system in practice.
Political and economic context
The weakness of representation belonged to a wider institutional order. Economic institutions were organized to enrich the tsar and nobility, supported by a mass system of coerced labor, particularly Russian serfdom. The Duma did not overturn this arrangement: political power remained concentrated, and economic rules continued to serve the interests of the ruling elite.
Significance
The Duma exemplifies how a formal political concession can coexist with the persistence of absolutism. In the book’s account, the obstacle to more inclusive institutions was not simply a lack of good policy advice, but the distribution of power and the interests it protected. The tsar’s ability to weaken the new assembly left that underlying structure largely intact.